Cookie of the Month Club



Give someone special six months or a full year of gourmet cookies by mail to show them how much you care. It’s the gift that keeps on giving.

Monthly programs are typically shipped on the first Tuesday of every month and follows this schedule:

The No Nutter – A dozen of all our handmade cookies made without nuts.

Sweets for my Sweet – A half dozen Snickerdoodle and a half dozen Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies.

Awww, Nuts! – A dozen of our assorted cookies made with premium nuts.

Specialty Chocolate Month – A dozen of our handmade cookies made with rich dark, milk and white chocolate.

The Works – Whatever we have fresh baked that week, you’ll receive.

Summer Surprise – Our Small Gift Box with a little extra keepsake from Carol’s treasure chest of swag.

Best Sellers – Whatever our best sellers are, you’ll be sent our top four.

“Fruit” of the Month – A half dozen each of our Oatmeal Raisin and Oatmeal Chocolate Cherry Cookies.

Minis – A Small Gift Box packed full of Carol’s Minis, containing Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin and Old-Fashioned Sugar.

Choco-holics – Every cookie we make with chocolate to sweeten up this month!

Tandem Coffee Cups – Two of our Carol’s Coffee Cups so you can sip and dip your way to a sweeter day.

Gourmet Assortment – Our finest assortment of gourmet cookies to try before those New Year’s Resolutions kick in.

Shipping and Pickup

Important Notes on Shipping & Pick Up Orders:

  • Shipping times may be negatively affected due to COVID-19 and labor-related issues at FedEx.
  • We ship on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays to ensure cookie freshness.
  • If you place an order after 1:00 pm (CST), your order will be released on the next possible ship date. All orders are shipping to arrive within TWO days due to the perishable nature of our handmade cookies.
  • We do offer a pickup option at our bakery in Northbrook, IL.
  • You may select “Pickup” as an option when placing your order.
  • If you have further questions, please visit our Shipping page for more details.